Cool-ship season Next box ships Order within Free shipping on 3+ boxes
Shipping within Idaho to start · Local meetup — free — in Rathdrum, Coeur d'Alene & Post Falls · Free shipping on 3+ boxes

Naturally flavored candy bar

Banana Creme Pie Candy Bars

The slice somebody always cut too big

Banana creme pie is the most underrated pie in America, and we will not be argued out of this. It's the one that showed up on the counter in a Pyrex dish, made by somebody who loved you, cut into slices that were frankly irresponsible.

This bar keeps that gentleness. The banana is ripe and mellow — closer to the pudding layer of the pie than to banana taffy — wrapped in a smooth vanilla-cream sweetness, with the graham cracker crunch doing the vanilla-wafer work underneath. Nothing sharp, nothing loud. It's a warm-kitchen kind of flavor.

Nobody else is making a banana creme pie candy bar. We checked. That alone makes it worth a spot in the box, and the people it's for already know who they are.

What's in the box

Nine individually wrapped Banana Creme Pie bars, 1.76 oz (50 g) each — NET WT 15.87 oz (450 g) of candy, about $3.33 a bar. Each one is poured in small batches in Rathdrum, Idaho, with no dyes, and shipped cold in insulated packaging.

Good to know

Round out the box

Freshly poured Banana Creme Pie candy bars in their molds, cream colored and flecked with graham cracker
Poured without dyes — the wrapper tells you it's Banana Creme Pie.
$29.99 per box of 9
$3.33 a bar

NET WT 15.87 oz (450 g) · Contains milk, wheat, soy.

Idaho shipping · free on 3+ boxes · Free local meetup: Rathdrum, CdA & Post Falls