Cool-ship season Next box ships Order within Free shipping on 3+ boxes
Shipping within Idaho to start · Local meetup — free — in Rathdrum, Coeur d'Alene & Post Falls · Free shipping on 3+ boxes

Naturally flavored candy bar

Key Lime Pie Candy Bars

Tart enough to wake you up, sweet enough to finish

There's a moment with real key lime pie — right when the tartness hits and your mouth waters before you've even swallowed — that most candy never gets close to. This bar gets close.

The lime comes on first, bright and green and puckery, the way it should. Then the sweet cream flavor of the shell smooths it out, and the graham cracker crunch lands underneath like the crust it's standing in for. Three notes, in the right order, the way the pie does it.

It's the sharpest bar in our lineup and the one tart-candy people reach for on the second order. If lemon is sunshine, key lime is the porch shade next to it — cooler, tangier, and a little smug about it.

What's in the box

Nine individually wrapped Key Lime Pie bars, 1.76 oz (50 g) each — NET WT 15.87 oz (450 g) of candy, about $3.33 a bar. Each one is poured in small batches in Rathdrum, Idaho, with no dyes, and shipped cold in insulated packaging.

Good to know

Round out the box

Freshly poured Key Lime Pie candy bars in their molds, cream colored and flecked with graham cracker
Poured without dyes — the wrapper tells you it's Key Lime Pie.
$29.99 per box of 9
$3.33 a bar

NET WT 15.87 oz (450 g) · Contains milk, wheat, soy.

Idaho shipping · free on 3+ boxes · Free local meetup: Rathdrum, CdA & Post Falls